Home Warranty Claims
Filing a claim sounds simple. When things go wrong - a denied claim, a long wait, or a small payout on a large HVAC job - knowing what to do next is the difference between getting paid and getting nothing.
Related guides
8
Service fee
$0-$150
Filing window
In your contract
The Claims Process - Overview
Something breaks
File a claim
Call or go online within the window your contract sets. Check the reporting deadline, because a late claim can be denied.
Pay the service fee
$0-$150 across the companies we track, paid when you schedule the visit. The contract says whether it is owed regardless of the outcome.
Contractor dispatched
Company sends a tech from their network - or you use your own if on a reimbursement plan.
Diagnosis submitted
The tech files a report. The company's review team approves or denies based on that report.
Approval or denial
Approved claims proceed to repair/replacement up to the coverage cap. Denied claims go to dispute.
Why Claims Get Denied
The three most common denial reasons - and what to do about each.
Pre-existing condition
Commonly disputedCompany claims the failure existed before your policy started. One of the most disputed denial categories.
Improper maintenance
Technician found neglected maintenance: dirty coils, unchanged filters, no annual tune-up documentation. Most policies require maintenance as a coverage condition.
Non-covered component
The specific failed part isn't listed in the covered-components section, even if the overall system is covered. Exclusions are explicit; unlisted = excluded.
Approved Doesn't Mean Fully Covered
The HVAC cap is the binding constraint - not the approval status.
$7,500
HVAC replacement cost (example)
$3,000
Coverage cap (example)
$4,500+
Your out-of-pocket (example)
This is why the cap matters more than the monthly premium. A plan without a per-unit HVAC cap, such as AFC Home Club's (read its review for the aggregate limit), leaves a smaller gap than a plan capped at a few thousand dollars on the same claim. The numbers above are an illustration, not a quote.
Claims Guides
Researching Before You Buy?
The best claim outcome is choosing a company with high caps and a clean denial history before anything breaks. See which companies actually pay out.
Claims processes, timelines, and consumer rights vary by company and state. This guide reflects general industry practices as of June 2026.
See how each company handles claims
Complaint records and contract terms differ by company. Our reviews cover BBB complaint data, regulatory history and plan terms.